Slashing earnings estimates significantly down

Historically, in one year, analysts’ EPS estimates (IBES F1) fell by about 4.4% for MSCI World, 1% for S&P500 and 3.9% for MSCI EMU.
We refer to the one year time frame which is needed to move from financial year 1 forward earnings (current 2020) to actual earnings (i.e. F1 to F0 in IBES terms). Every calendar estimate has a life duration of four years and the typical decay is -22% in the period (for EMU), 76% in the worst case, with a very high standard deviation of 25%.

Highlights:

  • We significantly cut our estimates for the US and EA and are currently 27% and 28% below the IBES consensus for the corresponding markets.
  • Risk premia are near Lehman times but earnings dispersion is still worrying and both economic and earnings consensus forecasts have more room for further downside.
  • Usually, after deep drops in earnings the first year of recovery sees huge earnings upside, above 30%. We are more conservative and use 20%.
  • On a 12-month horizon, even using as input -38% and -30% earnings cut from peak (euro area and US resp.), we see the chance to realize double digit total returns, which encourage us to adopt a limited overweight on equities.
  • Risks: postponed contagion peak and cities’ lockdown with further negative impact to the economy and earnings forecasts.

Download the full publication below

SLASHING EARNINGS ESTIMATES SIGNIFICANTLY DOWN

RELATED INSIGHTS

COVID-19 FACTS & FIGURES
According to the IMF’s Managing Director, strong international cooperation on coronavirus vaccine could speed up the world economic recovery and add $9 trillion to global income by 2025. A WHO trial found that Remdesivir, Hydroxychloroquine, Lopinavir and Interferon have little or no effect on hospitalized Covid-19 patients. Gilead Sciences has questioned the findings of the WHO study saying data appeared inconsistent.
INCORPORATING QUANT SIGNALS INTO EU EQUITY SECTOR/STYLE STRATEGY: MAINTAIN A TILT TO CYCLICALS AND VALUE
We present an update of our proprietary equity valuation tool, based on quant models. It provides indications of over- or undervaluation for different sectors and styles of European equities, which is further enriched by our qualitative analysis. Currently, among European equity sectors, financials, energy, telecoms, and autos look undervalued while Pharma, utilities and software appear overvalued.
CHINA’S RECOVERY CONTINUED BUT A BIT SOFTER THAN EXPECTED
China's economic recovery continued in Q3 2020, although a bit softer than expected. Real GDP growth rose to 4.9% yoy, slightly below the Reuters consensus expectation of 5.2% yoy, but still a substantial upturn from the 3.2% yoy in Q2. On a quarterly base, growth dynamics softened to 2.7% qoq, after 11.7% qoq and -10% qoq in the two previous quarters.