Core matters | Equity valuation: a multipronged assessment centred on earnings and risk premium

In Short

Equities play a pivotal role in asset allocation. In this publication, we describe our approaches to stock market valuation to obtain a broad market assessment to support investment decisions. They help us forecast 1-year as well as longer-term (3-to-5-years) total returns (TR) for different equity indices.

Highlights:

• This paper presents our enriched equity valuation frame- work, which is aimed at forecasting 1-year as well as longer- term (3-to-5-year) total return (TR) for equity indices.

• The future performance of the equity market will largely hinge on earnings growth. To this end, we make our own earnings assessment, comparing it with the consensus.

• We then take a multipronged approach to valuation. We look at current market multiples’ premium/discount as well as at the equity risk premium (ERP, i.e. the extra return over risk free rates to compensate for the risk) vs. history. ERP is a function of real yields, long-term earnings growth and eco- nomic and political uncertainty.

• For the S&P 500 only (better data availability), we also use the one century Shiller series for inflation-adjusted earnings and market multiples, i.e. CAPE or cyclically adjusted price- to-earnings ratio. Moreover, we measure the distance of current ERP to its historical average when inflation was comparable to current levels.   

• Additionally, we run traditional regression models to check market fair value and PE targets – using macro inputs as explanatory variables – as well as Machine Learning (ML) to assess future total returns.

• A final qualitative assessment along with proprietary valuation country scores is performed in ranking the attractiveness of market indices and overweight/underweight decisions within the equity space.

• Based on our analysis, we conclude that there is no particular hype in the US market valuation in the short term, although there is some exuberance from a longer-term perspective. This may ultimately imply lower future equity returns relative to bonds over the coming years (ca. +2-3% spread): 7% equity TR vs 4% Treasury. This compares to a higher TR spread of +4-6% over the past decades

Core matters: Equity valuation: a multipronged assessment centred on earnings and risk premium
Picture

© Generali Investments, all rights reserved. This website is provided by Generali Investments Luxembourg S.A. (Generali Investments) and is considered as a marketing communication and financial promotion related its products and services. This website may contain information related to the activity of the following companies: Generali Asset Management S.p.A. Società di gestione del risparmio, Infranity, Sycomore Asset Management, Aperture Investors LLC (including Aperture Investors UK Ltd), Plenisfer Investments S.p.A. Società di gestione del risparmio, Lumyna Investments Limited, Sosteneo S.p.A. Società di gestione del risparmio, Generali Real Estate S.p.A. Società di gestione del risparmio, Conning* and among its subsidiaries Global Evolution Asset Management A/S - including Global Evolution USA, LLC and Global Evolution Fund Management Singapore Pte. Ltd - Octagon Credit Investors, LLC, Pearlmark Real Estate, LLC as well as Generali Investments CEE. *Includes Conning, Inc., Conning Asset Management Limited, Conning Asia Pacific Limited, Conning Investment Products, Inc., Goodwin Capital Advisers, Inc. (collectively, “Conning”).